This episode has the mid-season climax. The Homecoming confrontation with Sylar that Isaac's paintings predicted. The confrontation that future Hiro hoped will change the course of fate. Save the cheerleader, save the world. We finally get to see the painting that Linderman bought because Nathan bought it back from him. He and Simone look at the painting and discuss it at the beginning of the episode before Nathan destroys it to "protect" Peter from himself. When we finally get to see the painting (because Simone had a digital copy) it shows what appears to be a dead Peter at the Homecoming game where Claire is going to be attacked.
It turns out Mr. Bennet's actions regarding Isaac did not result in him painting anything that would help them stop Sylar. He just erased the weeks of him getting clean for nothing. Since he can't convince the empath lady to make him go again, Mr. Bennet decides to ground Claire to stop her going to the homecoming game. It does not work, because her friend (the one who was tape recording her attempts) comes to help her sneak out. Claire's mom knows this is happening but doesn't stop it because she sees Mr. Bennet's actions as being unreasonable.
Meanwhile, Simone shows Peter the digital copy and he tries to call Hiro to tell him, but Hiro is still gone. Ando answers the phone. Peter flies to Texas and meets up with Ando, but Hiro is still nowhere to be found. Ando finally sees the picture on the wall of Hiro which was taken 6 months ago at Charlie's birthday party. The waitress says that Hiro popped out of Charlie's life weeks ago. Ando still has no idea where or when Hiro might be.
In Niki, Micah and DL's story, Micah keeps trying to convince DL to go back for his mom, but DL will not listen. He tells him that Niki is different and that it's not safe with her. Micah keeps begging his father and finally breaks down and tells him about Jessica (Niki's alter ego). Meanwhile, Jessica purchases a long-range sniper rifle so she can take out DL without him phasing out since he won't see it coming. The man selling her the rifle muses that she really must hate the guy she's out to get since she wants to take him out without even seeing his eyes (this seems a bit strange to me because it would seem more like she hated him if she wanted to gun him down from close range). I feel like this move might be so that Micah doesn't suspect that she was the one who pulled the trigger, since killing his father might make Micah hate her forever. Although Jessica does look in the mirror after buying the rifle and we briefly see Niki looking slightly distraught, the audience can't tell if she is against the idea because she still loves DL, knows it will devastate Micah, or because she is just against killing in general. Whatever is the case, she obviously is not strong enough to take back her body to stop Jessica.
At the homecoming dance, Jackie (the cheerleader who took credit for Claire's heroic act) and Claire fight in the locker room. Claire confesses that it was her who saved the man from the fire and tells Jackie that she has it on tape. While they're still in the locker room, Sylar shows up. He grabs Jackie and flings Claire against the wall. He begins to saw Jackie's head off when and actually finishes killing her before he notices that Claire is actively healing from the numerous injuries that resulted from his violently tossing her away. He then begins to pursue Claire, but Peter finds her and they both run together. Claire is able to get away (not before the scene in two of Issac's painting's comes true. Her frightened on the steps and Jackie with her head cut open) and Peter manages to grab Sylar and jump off a high ledge seriously injuring them both. The clock (which was at 8:12 in the painting which seemed to depict Peter dead) gets to that minute just before they land right in front of the homecoming banner. All the paintings have come true exactly as they were painted, but Claire sees Peter and Sylar has already gotten away. Claire goes to him and he immediately begins to regenerate. By the time the police show up, he has not a scratch on him, but he is covered in blood. The police arrest him as he protests.
Sylar is limping when he meets the Empath who tells him he doesn't want to hurt her right before the Hatian shows up to neutralize his power. It looks like they won and stopped Sylar, but we know that this can't be the case because the season is nowhere near over.
Meanwhile, back in India, Mohinder struggles with what he should do. He goes to find the boy, his friend on the university arguing with him all the way, telling him that the boy is just a figment of his subconscious mind. Mohinder realizes that Chadra was trying to protect him when the boy shows him a memory of Chandra arguing with the same man and being told that he'll lose all credibility if he continues down this path and then a memory of him excitedly coming to Chandra about his book only to be told he's too emotional to be a scientist and that he should stay here rather than accompany Chandra in his journey. He then decides to continue his father's research and figures out that his sister's name Shanti is the password to unlock his father's computer drive with the answers. It turns out, Chandra has found a lot of people with the genetic marker and has them all in a database. Mohinder decides to go back to America against his mother's wishes.
This was a good episode. The acting was very convincing, and I wasn't pulled out of the story at all. All of the stories shown helped to move along the plot and even though Sylar's face was still kept in shadow we got to see a lot more of him. I'm pretty sure he didn't speak (although I may be remembering that wrong) but I enjoyed the scenes with him and am fairly confident that we'll get a face reveal in the near future. Since Hiro's story ended with how the picture of him and Charlie happened, we can expect the next episode to explore his time in the past. Ando from the future told the police in New York that he had not seen Hiro in five weeks, so there might not be a scene of them reconciling and Ando might end up heading back to Japan after this. Not sure about that. I have watched it before but have forgotten some details. Nathan Petrelli is still annoying AF, but I suppose he really was trying to protect Peter by destroying the painting. I'll give this episode a 9/10.