This episode was really good. It did a bit of a bait and switch with the viewer by showing the end result of a situation which Veronica feels somewhat responsible for without letting the viewer know exactly what has happened just that it was a serious crime and that someone was injured enough to be carried out of the apartment on a stretcher.
The show was also interspersed with various flashbacks of Veronica and Lilly and the aftermath of Duncan breaking up with Veronica (which I had previously thought happened after Lilly's murder). The show begins with Veronica talking to her pregnant neighbor Sarah who has just had a fight with her boyfriend. Veronica is concerned about the nature of the fight, but Sarah says it was silly. She finally admits that she accused her boyfriend of stealing her journal out of jealousy. Sarah asks Veronica to drive her to a doctor's appointment but the morning after Veronica hears a mysterious thump in the apartment above (where Sarah and her boyfriend live) Sarah goes missing despite her appointment. Veronica tries looking into it by herself first. The boyfriend claims that she just ran away because she does that sometimes. Veronica asks about the fight she overheard. It turns out that her boyfriend had told her mother that she was pregnant and that really upset Sarah.
When Sarah's parents (mom and stepdad) express concern about her disappearance, Veronica suggests they hire her father to investigate. After hearing the story as told by her mother, how Sarah was a troubled teen who ran away from home because she couldn't handle her mom getting remarried, I immediately suspected SA by the stepfather. That's not where the bait and switch comes in. Upon further investigation, Veronica learns that Sarah was sexually assaulted before she left home. She figures out that her coworker was the one who stole her journal and convinces him to hand it over to her after asking Eli (AKA Weevil) to intimidate him with his biker gang. The man caves and hands over the journal which helps Veronica find Sarah but does not tell her who might have rape the poor girl. Prior to that, it was strongly suggested that Sarah might have been killed by the boyfriend in a jealous rage. He is shown helping his female friend move two large suitcases (which would be large enough to hold a human body). Veronica's dad follows them and confronts him but without any evidence, has to let them go. Veronica calls Sarah's doctor and finds out that her test results came back and it was a paternity test on her baby. Her boyfriend is not the father. That is how Veronica first discovered that Sarah was raped because the coworker knew, it's also how Veronica figured out that he was the one who stole Sarah's journal.
It turns out my theory was right. I really thought the crime was going to be Sarah shooting both her mother and stepfather, especially when she confronts both of them after her boyfriend has left to go to his studio and paint. The confrontation does end in someone getting shot, but it's the stepdad after he tackles Sarah when she pulls a gun on him after telling her mother what he did. Veronica's dad manages to get there just as he was about to attack Sarah again after wrestling the gun away from her and shoots him in the arm to disarm him.
During this, the flashbacks we get of Veronica's unceremonious breakup with Duncan suggest (along with the fact that Veronica's mom used to date his father) that perhaps what caused him to dump her is the knowledge that they are actually brother and sister. Something Veronica's father said also suggests this when he says a man has to be totally in love to agree to raise another man's baby. I now think that perhaps Lilly Kane was murder because of this information and perhaps Veronica's mother was even the one who did it.
This episode also had an interesting dynamic form between Eli and Logan. They end up in detention together after dissing a teacher during class. When they try to alleviate the boredom by playing a bit of poker. The teacher catches them and starts making them do chores for him as part of their punishment including washing his car and reorganizing his bookshelf. Eli has an idea and Logan decides to help him execute it. Somehow (don't ask me how) they end up getting the teacher's car impaled by the flagpole. Eli is caught (they claim to have a witness, but the teacher just suspects him) but refuses to give up his accomplice. Logan then goes to confess to helping him but uses his leverage as one of the rich kids to get the principle to un-expel Eli. The end up painting over graffiti instead which is when Logan notices the tattoo on Eli's shoulder that says Lilly. He gets irate about it, but Eli claims to have a younger sister named Lilly. We know from earlier scenes that Eli had some kind of feelings for Lilly, but not exactly what was going on between them. The tattoo suggests it might have been romantic, but there's no guarantee. If so, that would suggest that Lilly was cheating on Logan (which his new girlfriend also did so if that were the case, yikes). During all the scenes between Eli and Logan I was noticing some serious tension and I wonder if they'll take their unlikely friendship as far as that. Probably not. They're both pretty major characters and, even if this show has had some LGBT rep in the past, none of them have played a significant role in the story. It would be cool, though. I give this episode an 8.5/10.