This episode was all about the new boyfriend Troy. It starts with him, Logan and a third guy named Luke having a weekend of fun in Mexico. Luke joins Logan and Troy with a piñata which is obviously full of drugs because of how he is acting. It is unclear to the audience if Logan or Troy know what is in the piñata because Luke lies to them about why he got it, saying all the other souvenir places were closed. The border patrol jokes "want to hand over your contraband?" and it seems like the trio might be done for, but he laughs and asks them to open the trunk. Next thing you know, they are eating at a restaurant on the US side of the border laughing and joking about their stay in Mexico.
When they start to leave, they notice that the car is missing. Troy calls Veronica and Luke is visibly on edge. The next day, Luke is at the gym and the man who should be spotting him threatens to harm him if Luke doesn't bring his package. Troy tells Veronica that if his father finds out the car is missing, he'll ship him off to military school, so he enlists her help in tracking it down. The car has an anti-theft device, but to turn it on, you need to report the car stolen, and Troy says he's afraid that if he does that, his father will find out he borrowed it to go to Mexico.
Veronica tries to find out stuff about the car using a PI website and Wallace asks her if she can find out anything about him. There's nothing earth shattering, as expected. Wallace is pretty tame. The website comes into play later. Veronica's dad gets a message from his new girlfriend while she's there, so Veronica confronts him about the relationship. He tells her he just didn't want to bring it up before things got serious but that he's having fun and really likes her.
Veronica then uses the website to look up the councilor, finding a failed marriage which she hasn't gotten a divorce from yet and a very old case of check fraud. Veronica and her dad have a fight about her meddling in his personal life, but he breaks things off with his girlfriend because he realizes that this means Veronica is not ready for him to start dating yet.
Luke asks Veronica to help him get his drugs back, but they find out that the car has already been chopped and resold and that the sale is untraceable. There is no way to find the car without turning on the tracker. They do find the piñata, just as one of the kids at a birthday party cracks it open and candy (not steroids) falls out. So not only is the car missing, but so are the drugs. Veronica tells Luke that the only thing to do is to raise the money he needs to pay back the dealer. He does and Veronica delivers it. The dealer tries to tell her that he and Luke aren't square. She brings her pitbull along so he can't hurt her and keeps everything in public even though he tries to pull her into his office (smart girl). She also snaps his picture. When he tells her that he's not going to let Luke off the hook just because he got his money back, Veronica says he'll regret it. She uses the picture to print a watch out for this man poster and sends it to the border patrol. The next time he tries to make a run for steroids, he is stopped.
Veronica sends out untraceable phones to all her mom's old friends and acquaintances hoping that if she gets at least one, she'll reach out. While going through her mom's things, Veronica finds a safety deposit box key and learns that her mother was having her followed back when she was dating Duncan Kain. During a flashback where she learns about who Veronica's boyfriend is, she accidentally burns the waffles she's making and is visibly upset when she had been teasing Veronica moments before. This deepens the underlying mystery of Lilly Kain's murder. It is unclear if the friendship with Lilly began after the relationship or happened as a result of it because there doesn't seem to be any reason why she would be okay with the friendship but not the relationship (unless Veronica and Duncan are actually related like Veronica's mom had another child who was adopted by the Kains or his mother had an affair with her father or vice versa). I think if it turns out the two of them were related, that the mom should have come clean about it, though.
Back in the present, Veronica tries to sweet talk a male employee into turning on the car's tracking device, but the female boss catches them and tells him they're not supposed to do it unless the car has been reported stolen. Later, that same woman activates the device when told to do so by Veronica's father who helps as a favor to her. Afterwards, he gives Veronica an envelope of facts that he's collected about Troy and tells her it's up to her if she opens it or not.
Veronica and Troy follow the signal and find that the tracking device has been fixed to a dog's collar. Someone is a step ahead.
After learning Troy's secrets, Veronica confronts him about the fact that he used to smuggle drugs at his old school, but he still claims not to have known about Luke's deal. True to what Troy said, after his father gets back he is shipped off in a taxi. He does not get off at Albuquerque, however, he gets off at the restaurant where his father's car went missing and hands someone a roll of cash. He goes into the bathroom and takes a package out of the vent then drives off in the same car that had gone missing. Turns out he was playing them all along. He calls his old girlfriend and she tells him that some girl named Veronica who knows him has been calling her. That's when he opens the package and finds candy in place of the steroids with a note from Veronica telling him that the drugs have been flushed down the toilet.
Veronica is asleep listening to music when her phone rings. Her mother is calling from one of the burner phones she sent. She says she misses her and that once everything comes out in the open it will be clear why she is acting the way that she's acting.
I liked this one, but it wasn't the best one ever. Did not see the surprise ending coming even after Troy's past was revealed. Wasn't too sure about the dad's relationship so him calling it off didn't really affect me. Troy's betrayal stung a bit more since Veronica did turn to him in her hour of need and seemed to be starting to trust again after what happened with Duncan and at the party. I rate this one a 6/10. No emotional scenes. Plot was kind of boring, although it did have that clever twist ending.